In the summer of 1974, a small group of amateur winemakers, including yours truly, formed a tasting group that met every other Wednesday. Ten years ago, we decided to meet just the first Wednesday every month. I eventually named this group the Wednesday Night Fatally-Flawed Palates. We have had some amazing tastings over the course of all these years, and I have watched our group of eight grow to include 21 fatally-flawed palates. The group is incredibly social, opinionated and highly vocal about what they like and don’t, always resulting in some very interesting tasting results. Although I have been working on compiling all my 39-plus years of tasting notes on my computer for a future manuscript, I have decided to begin posting the results of each tasting here on our K&L Blog.
There is always a central theme at each tasting, the wines are tasted blind and rankings are based on the total rankings from each taster—really empirical. On Wednesday, February 2nd, we conducted, for the first time ever, a Beaujolais tasting from the stunningly great 2009 vintage. The rankings, below, and subsequent scores, with commentary, are from my score sheet. The pricing is K&L’s, which is the best in the universe. I still use the old-fashioned UC Davis Scoring System (how unique versus the hundred point system created by the self-anointed demi-gods?), which awards one point to the top-ranked wine, two to the second wine, three to the third and so on. This means the lower the score the better. Like golf.
First: Georges Duboeuf Julienas "La Trinquée" ($14.99) Medium-deep ruby in color, this wine possesses aromas of a well-made Côtes-du-Nuits-Villages Burgundy, with meaty undertones, and upfront, opulent notes of violets and cherries. In the mouth it is bright and flashy, with some oak, wonderful complexity and a pretty, lengthy finish. (Earned 48 total points based on the following rankings: 0 people ranked it first, 3 ranked it second, 4 third, 5 fourth, 2 fifth, 0 sixth, 0 seventh, and 0 eighth. I ranked it fifth out of the eight wines, with 18 points.
Second: Domaine de Collett Regnie "Vieilles Vignes" ($14.99) Medium-deep ruby in color, bright, flashy, pretty aromas of wild plum and cherry. Its Burgundian floral notes are distinctive and well-defined. In the mouth, this beauty is lush, broad, framed by cedary oak, with good complexity, soft tannins (?), hints of minerality and a fairly long finish, which is quite unusual for Gamay Noir. (51 total points: 2/1/4/4/0/2/1/0. I ranked it third with 18 ½ points.)
Third: Domaine Foillard Morgon "Cuvée Corcelette" ($32.99) Medium-deep ruby in color. A bit austere at first, but opening to show a ton of red fruits and rose petals; pronounced, bright and distinctive. Bright, flashy, lush fruit on the palate, with good complexity, excellent structure and a long, warm finish. A great Beaujolais. (58 total points: 2/4/1/0/3/0/2/2. I ranked it second with 19 points.)
Fourth: Domaine Julien Sunier Regnie ($18.99) Medium-ruby in color, with a bright, pretty nose of strawberry and violets. Bright flavors, simple and linear. The finish falls off, though. (61 total points: 3/2/2/0/2/0/2/3. I ranked it eighth with 17 points.)
Fifth: Domaine du Vissoux, Moulin-à-Vent "Trois Roches" ($27.99) Medium-deep ruby in color; the aromas are bright, flashy and red-fruited driven, with floral undertones. Balanced, red-fruited fruit flavors, with good complexity, and a lovely, pretty, lingering finish. This is a near-term puppy that drinks great right now. (63 total points: 1/2/1/3/3/0/4/0. I ranked it seventh with 18 points.)
Sixth: Château De Pizay Morgon ($13.99) Inky in color—I have never seen a Beaujolais this deep in color. Opulent aromas of currants, blackberries and rose petals that are ripe and lush. (This is Beaujolais?) Deep, rich flavors that are complex, with excellent complexity, concentration and fullness, with intense flavors and an amazing length. The major complaint with my tasting group was that this was too big to be a Beaujolais, and I agree, but it is a phenomenal wine, regardless. (65 total points: 3/2/0/0/2/2/4/1. I ranked it first with 19 ½ points and the comment: “One of the greatest “young” Beaujolais that I have ever tasted!”)
Seventh: Domaine du Vissoux Brouilly "Pierreux" ($26.99) Medium-deep ruby in color, the bouquet was opulent and pronounced, with bright plummy to rose petal floral notes, while in the mouth, this Gem is deeply flavored, complex, fleshy and showing brilliant, vibrant fruit. The finish is long and satisfying. (67 total points: 2/0/2/2/1/5/0/2. I ranked this fourth with 18 ½ points.)
Eighth: Henry Fessy Fleurie ($16.99) Medium-deep ruby in color, the nose shows rose petal tones and is plummy with good opulence and lush, ripe tones. This Gem is incredibly balanced and fleshy, with good complexity and depth of flavor, plus a wonderful structure and a long, warm finish. (91 total points: 1/0/0/0/1/5/1/6. I ranked it sixth with 18 points.)
Every so often, we have a tasting that totally frustrates this group, and does so because the quality of the wines are so close that it becomes almost impossible to rank them. This was one such tasting. Please note that the first place wine from Duboeuf received no first place votes, but won the tasting. My personal feeling is that the most amazing wine in this tasting was the Morgon from Pizay. The group didn’t know what to do with it—and, yes, in terms of how we view Beaujolais, this wine is atypical. But, so are the rest. In any case, this was a wonderful tasting that needed no excuses for the ranking results.